60+ Halloween Would You Rather Questions & Free Printable

Halloween is the perfect time to get silly and play some games, including Would You Rather! 

There are dozens of “this or that” Halloween questions here for younger kids right up to tweens and teens to make the spooky season fun. 

You could play this game at a Halloween party or introduce these questions while you are out trick-or-treating as a fun way to pass the time between houses. 

This makes the perfect Halloween activity for toddlers, as well as a great conversation-starter at parties for kids of all ages. 

You could even ask these questions at the breakfast table on Halloween morning. 

There’s a free printable Halloween Would You Rather activity sheet for you to print out here too. Print off as many copies as you need and hand them out to kids at a party. Get them to circle their answers and then compare what they had to say. 

Why play Would You Rather at Halloween?

Asking these silly questions is a perfect way to pass the time if you are looking for an activity that does not involve trick-or-treating or eating candy at Halloween.

It’s also a great way to get kids to use their creativity. They don’t just have to answer each question, they can explain why with every answer. This can get funny and a little crazy, as everyone may have a different view on whether they want to be a vampire bat or a black cat!

If you have kids of various different ages this game is perfect as everyone can get involved – thought they may disagree over the answers!

Let’s check out the questions. 

Halloween Would You Rather questions for younger children

1. Would you rather dress as a pumpkin or a ghost?
2. Would you rather get 100 small candies or 10 big ones?
3. Would you rather have a pet bat or a pet black cat?
4. Would you rather go trick-or-treating or visit a haunted house?
5. Would you rather go trick-or-treating in the rain or in the snow?
6. Would you rather wear a superhero costume or a monster costume?
7. Would you rather eat candy corn or pumpkin pie?
8. Would you rather have a talking skeleton friend or a singing zombie friend?
9. Would you rather carve a pumpkin or paint one?
10. Would you rather sleep in a haunted house for one night or not eat candy for a week?
11. Would you rather have a jack-o’-lantern for a head or ghost feet?
12. Would you rather ride on a witch’s broom or fly with a vampire cape?
13. Would you rather be invisible like a ghost or howl like a werewolf?
14. Would you rather get scared by a jump scare or by spooky music?
15. Would you rather go to a costume party or trick-or-treat all night?
16. Would you rather be best friends with a friendly mummy or a kind vampire?
17. Would you rather eat only Halloween candy for a day or no candy for a month?
18. Would you rather wear a costume every day for a week or never again?
19. Would you rather turn into a black cat or a tiny bat for one day?
20. Would you rather tell a spooky story or listen to one?
21. Would you rather get stuck in a cobweb or chased by a scarecrow?
22. Would you rather have fangs or a witch’s nose?
23. Would you rather have a witch’s broom or a crystal ball?
24. Would you rather have a black cat or an owl?
25. Would you rather have a trick or a treat?
26. Would you rather watch a scary movie or read a scary book?
27. Would you rather have only candy or only chocolate?

Halloween Would You Rather questions for tweens and teens

1. Would you rather spend the night in a haunted mansion or camp in a dark forest?
2. Would you rather be chased by zombies or by vampires?
3. Would you rather be a witch for a day or a ghost for a week?
4. Would you rather have glowing red eyes or a long werewolf tail?
5. Would you rather get a jump scare every hour or hear creepy whispers all day?
6. Would you rather have to survive in a horror movie or in a post-apocalyptic world?
7. Would you rather be turned into a toad by a witch or bitten by a vampire?
8. Would you rather eat a bowl of “witch’s stew” or drink “zombie juice”?
9. Would you rather accidentally summon a ghost or a demon?
10. Would you rather explore a creepy abandoned asylum or an old graveyard at midnight?
11. Would you rather have to say “Boo!” to everyone for a day or laugh like a witch every time you speak?
12. Would you rather have Halloween every day or never celebrate it again?
13. Would you rather walk through a corn maze full of scarecrows or a foggy forest full of whispers?
14. Would you rather watch horror movies alone in the dark or walk through a haunted house with strangers?
15. Would you rather find a cursed object in your attic or a hidden passage in your basement?
16. Would you rather trick-or-treat until 3 a.m. or eat only candy for 3 days?
17. Would you rather be locked in a room with a creepy doll or a mysterious mirror?
18. Would you rather live next door to Dracula or Frankenstein’s monster?
19. Would you rather wear an itchy costume for 24 hours or face your biggest fear for 5 minutes?
20. Would you rather have to eat animal livers or animal eyeballs?
21. Would you rather be the villain in a horror movie or the first character to die?
22. Would you rather carve 20 pumpkins or decorate 100 cookies?
23. Would you rather meet a ghost who wants to be your roommate or a werewolf who needs help finding their pack?
24. Would you rather feel like you’re being watched or hear footsteps behind you all night?
25. Would you rather go ghost hunting with friends or spend Halloween doing a scary escape room?
26. Would you rather lose your voice every Halloween or have glowing eyes for the whole week?
27. Would you rather be trapped in a nightmare or stuck inside a scary movie?
28. Would you rather be cursed to always hear spooky laughter or see shadowy figures in mirrors?
29. Would you rather turn into a skeleton at night or sneeze spiders for a week?
30. Would you rather host a haunted dinner party or plan a horror-themed scavenger hunt?
31. Would you rather visit a haunted house or an escape room?
32. Would you rather have pumpkin spice or caramel apple?
33. Would you rather watch horror movies or listen to ghost stories around the campfire?
34. Would you rather be able to move through walls for one day or see through walls for one day?
35. Would you rather drink a super strength potion or a super invisibility potion?

Free printable game

Here’s a free printable featuring some of the questions from the list above in a simple format. This is perfect for kids of all ages.

Download and print as many copies as you need!